Established Fact
The Butler County, Pennsylvania Board of Commissioners formally declined CTCL funding, with Commissioner Kimberly Geyer documenting in an official narrative submitted to the United States Department of Justice that acceptance would compromise election integrity by subjecting county operations to the influence of “a private/public entity.” The same document, co-signed by Commissioner Leslie Osche as Chairman, identified Zuckerberg’s media/tech philanthropy and Progress PA among the external forces that the commissioners concluded had targeted Butler County — a stronghold carried by Trump with 72% of the vote in 2016 — as part of a broader effort to influence the 2020 election outcome. The document further records that Governor Wolf withheld federal CARES Act election funding from Lebanon County for over a month in 2020, releasing it only on August 14, 2020 — a period during which CTCL private funding was simultaneously flowing to Democratic-leaning Pennsylvania counties that had received preferential early access to the grant program. This contemporaneous, official county-level record of CTCL rejection and documented concern about external targeting provides direct evidentiary support for the partisan design theory. The acceptance of CTCL funds by counties concurrently receiving federal HAVA and CARES Act assistance raises the additional question of whether the grant conditions subjected county election officials to the strictures of the federal program fraud statute.
Citations
Kimberly D. Geyer, Vice Chairman, Butler County Board of Commissioners, “Election Timeline for Butler County, Pennsylvania” (Nov. 12, 2020), at entry dated 9/2/20 (“Butler County declined to accept these funds to protect the integrity of their election system in Butler County from being influenced by a private/public entity.”), produced as Exhibit 7 to Senate Judiciary Committee, Examination of the DOJ’s Efforts to Investigate Alleged Election Fraud in the 2020 Election, transmitted by Rep. Scott Perry to Dep. AG Richard Donoghue, Dec. 27, 2020, available at https://www.judiciary.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Donoghue%20Ex%207%20-%20Redacted.pdf
For Butler County’s non-receipt of CTCL funds, see Foundation for Government Accountability, “Pennsylvania Zuckerbucks Brief” (Mar. 16, 2021) (listing 23 Pennsylvania CTCL grant recipients; Butler County absent), available at https://thefga.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Pennsylvania-Zuckerbucks-brief-3-16-21.pdf; Broad + Liberty (Apr. 13, 2021) (documenting CTCL grants were “heavily skewed toward ‘blue’ counties”), available at https://broadandliberty.com/2021/04/13/zuckerberg-funded-grants-skewed-toward-blue-counties/.