Disputed Fact [Disputed Fact – As to intent and whether destruction was authorized] Named witness Regina Miller testified that she personally observed Delaware County official Thomas Gallagher and county employee James Ziegelhoffer physically tear election data – including machine tapes and return sheets – into pieces and place them in the trash. Ziegelhoffer was reported […]
Established Fact [Established Fact – Eyewitness testimony documented; internal emails authenticated; blank ballot discovery confirmed] Named witness Regina Miller testified that she personally observed Delaware County official Thomas Gallagher and county employee James Ziegelhoffer physically tear election data – including machine tapes and return sheets – into pieces and place them in the trash. Ziegelhoffer
Disputed Fact [Disputed Fact – Extent of missing applications and ballot count of late delivery contested] A forensic audit by Speckin Forensics of sampled Wayne County TCF Center Absentee Voter Counting Boards determined that up to 20% of absentee ballots in the sampled boards lacked the legally required absentee ballot application – the instrument that
Established Fact [Established Fact – Speckin forensic finding and sworn testimony as to 3:30 AM delivery confirmed] A forensic audit by Speckin Forensics of sampled Wayne County TCF Center Absentee Voter Counting Boards determined that up to 20% of absentee ballots in the sampled boards lacked the legally required absentee ballot application – the instrument
TCF Center 3:30 AM Ballot Delivery Without Chain-of-Custody Manifests (MI) Read More »
Reasonable Inference [Established Fact – Dominion operational control confirmed; FIPS violation confirmed; EAC certification timing confirmed] The EOG Report concluded that Dominion Voting Systems personnel were in operational control of voting systems in nearly every Georgia county during the election period. This determination is critical to the record destruction findings: the personnel with the greatest
Established Fact The EOG Report documents that 35 tabulator memory cards were swapped mid-election in Fulton County – an event for which no chain-of-custody documentation exists. Memory card swapping during an active election is not a standard procedure and introduces the possibility that cards containing accumulated vote totals were replaced with cards containing different data.
Established Fact Official records confirm that Fulton County certified 17,852 recount votes for which no corresponding ballot image exists – ballots that were counted in the official recount but have no digital record. The EOG Report further documents 20,713 ballots tied to tabulators with “no provenance” – meaning they cannot be traced back to any
Established Fact In response to a Request for Admissions filed in Curling v. Raffensperger, Fulton County expressly “Admitted” that it “did not preserve until the present time the majority of ballot images from in-person voting for the November 3, 2020 election original machine count.” The EOG Report documents the specific scope of destruction in Fulton
Disputed Fact Forensic document examiner Erich Speckin, retained as part of the Arizona Senate audit, reported that approximately 23,000 ballots appeared to have been printed from a source other than the official ballot PDF on file with Maricopa County. He further documented that 58 batches of ballots (approximately 11,600 ballots) from early voting favored one
Established Fact Post-election audit confirmed that boxes of ballots delivered to auditors contained commingled original damaged ballots and their machine duplicates, inconsistently identified, with batch manifests that did not match physical contents. In the documented example of Box EVH1/11-07/MC17349, the manifest listed 14 batches of original ballots while the box physically contained 7 original and
