Michigan

Bailey v. Antrim County, No. 2020-9238-CZ (Antrim Co. Cir. Ct.) – Only Case with Forensic Discovery; Dismissed When Remedies Satisfied, Not for Lack of Merit (MI)

Antrim County, Established Fact, Information Control, Michigan, Misinformation/Disinformation Policy, United States /

Established Fact Bailey v. Antrim County is the most analytically significant Michigan case for this investigation. Judge Kevin Elsenheimer granted a preliminary injunction authorizing forensic examination of Antrim County’s tabulating machines, thumb drives, and memory cards – the only such order in Michigan. The case was ultimately dismissed when the court found all requested remedies […]

Bailey v. Antrim County, No. 2020-9238-CZ (Antrim Co. Cir. Ct.) – Only Case with Forensic Discovery; Dismissed When Remedies Satisfied, Not for Lack of Merit (MI) Read More »

Michigan SOS “Fact-Check” Page – Valid Election Fraud Claims Labeled as Misinformation (MI)

Disputed Fact, Information Control, Michigan, Misinformation/Disinformation Policy, United States /

Disputed Fact [Disputed Fact – Legal characterization] The Michigan Secretary of State’s office established and maintained a public-facing “SOS Fact-Check” web page during and after the 2020 election, which was used to label specific citizen affidavits, audit claims, and investigative findings as “misinformation” or “debunked.” The page utilized state government resources and the official authority

Michigan SOS “Fact-Check” Page – Valid Election Fraud Claims Labeled as Misinformation (MI) Read More »

Michigan SOS “Fact-Check” Page – Media Coordination (MI)

Disputed Fact, Information Control, Michigan, Misinformation/Disinformation Policy, United States /

Disputed Fact [Disputed Fact – Coordination with media] The Michigan Secretary of State’s office established and maintained a public-facing “SOS Fact-Check” web page during and after the 2020 election, which was used to label specific citizen affidavits, audit claims, and investigative findings as “misinformation” or “debunked.” The page utilized state government resources and the official

Michigan SOS “Fact-Check” Page – Media Coordination (MI) Read More »

Michigan SOS “Fact-Check” Page (MI)

Established Fact, Information Control, Michigan, Misinformation/Disinformation Policy, United States /

Established Fact [Established Fact – Page existed] The Michigan Secretary of State’s office established and maintained a public-facing “SOS Fact-Check” web page during and after the 2020 election, which was used to label specific citizen affidavits, audit claims, and investigative findings as “misinformation” or “debunked.” The page utilized state government resources and the official authority

Michigan SOS “Fact-Check” Page (MI) Read More »

Michigan State Board of Canvassers Certified Statewide Election Despite Explicit Notice That Wayne County Certification Was Legally Defective (MI)

Election Results Certification Integrity, Established Fact, Michigan, State Certification, United States /

Established Fact On November 23, 2020, the Michigan Board of State Canvassers certified the 2020 general election via a 3-0 vote, with Republican member Norman Shinkle abstaining. The certification proceeded despite Shinkle having been explicitly notified – and having raised on the record – that the underlying Wayne County certification was legally invalid, lacking the

Michigan State Board of Canvassers Certified Statewide Election Despite Explicit Notice That Wayne County Certification Was Legally Defective (MI) Read More »

Media Dismissal of Sworn Affidavits to Protect Unofficial Results – TCF Center (MI)

Detroit, Election Results Certification Integrity, Michigan, Reasonable Inference, United States, Unofficial Reporting, Wayne County /

Reasonable Inference Media outlets across Michigan and nationally used unofficial election-night results to establish an expectation of decisive victory, then systematically characterized hundreds of sworn, notarized affidavits from TCF Center poll workers and observers as “baseless,” “unsubstantiated,” or already “debunked.” These affidavits detailed election administration chaos including the boarding of windows to prevent lawful observation,

Media Dismissal of Sworn Affidavits to Protect Unofficial Results – TCF Center (MI) Read More »

Pre-Meditated FOIA Obstruction Intended to Prevent Access to Machine Audit Detailed Technical Report (MI)

Audit, Election Results Certification Integrity, Macomb Countty, Michigan, Reasonable Inference, United States /

Reasonable Inference The office of Macomb County Clerk Anthony Forlini engaged in pre-meditated FOIA obstruction when they reached out to the office of MI Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson and ES&S representatives for guidance on how to prevent disclosure of the audit records. Macomb County subsequently denied FOIA requests for such records using the rationale

Pre-Meditated FOIA Obstruction Intended to Prevent Access to Machine Audit Detailed Technical Report (MI) Read More »

Fake Forensic Audit of ES&S System (MI)

Audit, Disputed Fact, Election Results Certification Integrity, Macomb Countty, Michigan, United States /

Disputed Fact In the wake of the 2020 election, incoming Macomb County Clerk Anthony Forlini contracted with Pro V&V to conduct what he referred to as a “forensic” audit of the ES&S. Cybersecurity expert Ben Cotton of CyFir was invited to observe the conduct of the audit but was not allowed to examine the equipment

Fake Forensic Audit of ES&S System (MI) Read More »

RLA Invalidated by Statutory Loopholes and Non-Compliance (MI)

Audit, Detroit, Election Results Certification Integrity, Established Fact, Michigan, United States, Wayne County /

Established Fact Michigan’s statewide Risk Limiting Audit was structurally compromised: under MCL 168.871, “out-of-balance” precincts are legally ineligible for hand recounts, and this rule was used to exclude roughly 71% of Detroit absentee counting boards from meaningful post-election scrutiny. Additionally, 21 county clerks simply failed to complete the required RLA, rendering the statutory “risk limit”

RLA Invalidated by Statutory Loopholes and Non-Compliance (MI) Read More »

Erasure of Adjudication Logs to Prevent Meaningful Audit (MI)

Antrim County, Audit, Disputed Fact, Election Results Certification Integrity, Michigan, United States /

Disputed Fact A court-ordered forensic examination in Antrim County documented a 68.05% tabulation error rate that routed large numbers of ballots to electronic adjudication. When auditors accessed the Dominion EMS, all 2020 adjudication log entries were missing, while adjudication logs for prior election years on the same system remained intact, making it impossible to reconstruct

Erasure of Adjudication Logs to Prevent Meaningful Audit (MI) Read More »